Featured Gallery, NBA / Mar 23, 2011 / 11:00 am

Top 5 Most Impactful NBA Playoff Injuries Of The Decade

Dirk Nowitzki

Dirk Nowitzki (photo. Monte Isom)

Yesterday, two Western Conference Playoff teams got red cards. Memphis, playing well as they waited for the return of Rudy Gay, found out their star is now done for the year with a partially dislocated shoulder. And San Antonio, the team with the best record in the League and riding an uncharacteristic wave of perfect health, lost Tim Duncan to a serious ankle injury. While one may be slightly more serious than the other, both players are expected to miss significant time with only a few weeks left until the playoffs start. These injuries figure to have a huge impact on just how far these teams can push themselves in April and May. Memphis probably isn’t winning anything, but for the Spurs, this could be devastating.

This weird timing seems to happen all the time. 2011 isn’t the first year, and certainly won’t be the last, when playoff teams have to deal with this. Here are five other examples of it in the past decade, and while most of these happened during the playoffs, the consequences are the same:

2003: Dirk Nowitzki and the Mavs

It’s hard to say how significant Dirk Nowitzki’s injury was during the 2003 Western Conference Finals. San Antonio had finally beaten L.A. in the semis, and looked better than they ever before. But so did Dallas and this was the best team the Mavs ever had with Dirk, Steve Nash and Michael Finley. The Mavs even won Game 1 behind Dirk (38 points, 15 rebounds) after trailing by 18. But late in Game 3 after Dallas had been ahead for much of the game, Nowitzki went down on a rebound with a sprained right knee. Buckling as he collided with Manu Ginobili, Dallas coach Don Nelson later conceded he wouldn’t play Dirk unless the German was 100 percent. Nowitzki never played again that year and San Antonio dominated the rest of the series and the NBA Finals.

2005: Joe Johnson and the Suns

This was supposed to be the year. Steve Nash. Amar’e Stoudemire. Shawn Marion. Joe Johnson. Out of all the years that Phoenix had a chance at a championship, that very first Lamborghini team in 2004-2005 was the best one. Before Johnson became an overpaid, yet perennial All-Star with Atlanta, he was the perfect off-ball wing option opposite Nash. That year, he averaged over 17 points while shooting nearly 50 percent from deep. Before the collision with Jerry Stackhouse that left J.J. with a left orbital bone fracture, Johnson had four straight 20-point playoff games and Phoenix looked poised for a probable title run. Could they have beaten San Antonio with him in the lineup? He wasn’t really himself again until Game 4 of that series, which happened to be the only game the Suns won in the Western Conference Finals.

2004: Sam Cassell and the Wolves

The only season Sam Cassell ever made an All-Star game was also the best shot Minnesota had of playing in the NBA Finals. That year, they made it all the way to the Western Conference Finals, riding Kevin Garnett and the perfect blend of role players to a meeting with the Lakers. That L.A. team was on the brink of falling apart and if Cassell hadn’t been forced to sit out the last two games of the series with hip and back problems, who knows? Garnett put up historic numbers (24.3 ppg, 14.6 rpg, 5.1 apg) during those playoffs, but it was Cassell who took and hit the big shots. Take a look at his conference finals numbers and tell me the Wolves couldn’t have won that series if he’s healthy (especially considering Darrick Martin was their next best option):

Game 1: couldn’t play in the fourth quarter because of the injury, still had 16 points, 8 assists
Game 2: left during the opening minute
Game 3: 18 points, but played only 26 minutes because of the injuries
Game 4: only five minutes because of his injury problems
Game 5: didn’t play
Game 6: didn’t play

2009: Kevin Garnett and the Celtics

How quickly people forget. A year after creating the largest single-season turnaround in league history and winning a ring, Boston started this season 27-2. While most figured on a repeat of the Celtics/Lakers Finals matchup, everything changed one February night in a loss in Utah. Late in the opening half, Garnett jumped for an alley-oop and came down hopping, trying to take pressure off his right knee. At first, the significance was unknown. Most figured he would be fine for the playoffs. But he never played and Boston lost in the second round. In fact, it took Garnett nearly two years to fully regain his health and the injury might’ve cost the Celtics a second championship last season when the Lakers beat up a wobbly Garnett inside to win it all.

2003: Chris Webber and the Kings

One year after losing Peja Stojakovic to an injury in the playoffs and falling to the Lakers in an epic Western Conference Final, Sacramento came back hungrier and deeper than ever. This was the most talented team the Kings of that era ever had, going at least two deep at every spot. It wasn’t a matter of if, but when they would break through. Chris Webber was the apex, a gliding and powerful tiger of a basketball player who had helped define Sacramento’s exciting style. But when Webber, who averaged 23 points, 10.5 rebounds and 5.4 assists that year, went down in the second game of their semifinal series against Dallas, it ended an era. The team was never the same again and lost to Dallas in a series that would’ve certainly been theirs if they had their best player. More importantly Webber’s career quickly fizzled out and ultimately died a few years later in Golden State; the franchise is still recovering from this.

What do you think?

Follow Sean on Twitter at @SEANesweeney.

Follow Dime on Twitter at @DimeMag.

Become a fan of Dime Magazine on Facebook HERE.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • north

    What about Perkins last year? I know he’s no star but most still believe that Perk’s injury was the reason LA won the chip. He was as important to that series as “Big Balls” Sam was for the T’wolves.

  • Big Meech

    Yao Ming and Dikembe Mutomobo for the Rockets?
    We lost Mutombo for the Blazers series and Yao went out in game 3 vs the Lakers.
    2008-2009 Season.
    We had that series! Closest to the Chip we’d been in forever!
    PG – Brooks, Lowry
    SG – Artest, Wafer
    SF – Battier,
    PF – Scola, Landry, Hayes,
    C – Yao, Mutombo

    with Dorsey, Barry, & others on the bench.

  • Promoman

    Chris Webber’s microfracture surgery is hands down the most pivotal injury of the decade. Chris went from a MVP contender/budding HOFer to a topic of debate as to whether or not he even deserves to have his jersey retired among a lot of people since his career ended over it. The Kings already got fucked in the 2002 Playoffs by the refs and that injury shut down their title opportunity.

  • Brown

    This is a great article Sean, nice work.

    I gotta go with C-Webb though. That Sacramento team is probably the best team to never make an NBA Finals. Their biggest injury though was when Robert Horry ripped out their collective souls.

    It’s crazy how Webber’s career did a nosedive after that. He’s still my favorite player of all time and I’m glad he retired a Warrior.

  • KB2424

    Kobe would be somewhere in that list too, but he never was a pussy and never sat out no matter what he had !

  • yoda

    what about bynum’s injury 2 years before? it would be different if lakers had him against boston that year

  • http://deleted dagwaller

    Really makes you think. Are the Spurs, Pistons, Lakers and Celtics of the last decade really that great…or just the luckiest when it comes to injuries?

    Were any of those title teams stricken with injuries? Imagine if instead of Dirk getting hurt, Kobe or TD had been the ones out for the season? We’d be saying that the Mavs won while that injury was up at the top of this list.


    Great article I had forgot about cassell injury major deal

  • Kyle

    Dirk and Webber in back to back series both destroyed their teams chances. Webber went down against Dallas, and then Dirk went down against Spurs. It gave the Spurs a huge opening to win it all. Good call…

    And you forgot about Yao against the Lakers(they had won the first game with him.) The Rockets’ hard work got them to see a game 7, but they didn’t have either one of their “superstars” since McGrady was also hurt as usual. Aaron Brooks couldn’t win it by himself.