6-Pack: Ranking The Best NBA Stars Still Alive

Dirk Nowitzki (photo. Monte Isom)
This is it. The final four. Winning time. Legacies are on the line (Dirk). Some are working for a name (KD, Westbrook, Rose). The dark side is looking for redemption (LeBron, Wade).
If you checked out Mike & Mike in the Morning earlier this week, you might’ve heard them rating the six superstars still left in the playoffs (Derrick Rose, LeBron James, Dwyane Wade, Dirk Nowitzki, Kevin Durant & Russell Westbrook). Who’s been the best in the playoffs? It’s a hard debate. All six have had their moments, and my list seems to change from game to game. Interestingly, look at the ages for these guys. Dirk is really the only one who shouldn’t be in his “prime.” The others are either babies (KD, Russ, Rose) or just coming into their own (‘Bron, Wade).
Which guys have been the best in the playoffs? Here are my rankings for the six superstars still alive (statistics courtesy of NBA.com’s StatsCube.)
*** *** ***
6. Russell Westbrook
The playoff vitals: 23.2 ppg, 6.5 apg, 5.2 rpg, 44.5 clutch USG %
No great player has taken as much heat during the postseason as this guy. You say you need a player with big cajones? Willing to take the clutch shots? Name me someone like this kid. He took the shots from the media, sucked ‘em in and then went out and played just as he always has. Yes, during Game 7 he was looking for teammates more often. But while playing a position he didn’t grow up playing, in just his third year, at just 22 years old, playing next to the NBA’s best scorer, on a team that desperately needs his leadership, in a firestorm of critics, his playoff run is a big f$%^ you to the critics. It was this guy who won the triple-OT Game 4 thriller against Memphis, playing 51 minutes and scoring 40 points, saving OKC’s season. It was this guy who laced a Game 7 with the first triple-double in nearly 20 years.
If OKC is to get to the Finals, Westbrook not only has to win his backcourt matchups but he has to dominate them. DeShawn Stevenson is going to check him? Please. It’ll come down to his response to the fourth-quarter benching. The Thunder need him. They need Westbrook attacking and aggressive. KD can’t do it alone. The next few games will define Westbrook’s season. Still, when there are five players playing better than Westbrook is right now, we’re in good hands.
5. Dwyane Wade
The playoff vitals: 25.3 ppg, 7.3 rpg, 4.6 apg, 1.8 spg, 48% shooting, third in playoff PER: 28.09
Against the Celtics, Wade was the difference, dominating at the start and finish of the series. In Game 1, he answered the questions about Boston defending him by going for 38 points and missing just seven shots. Then, his three-pointer clinched Game 4 before he played one of the best games of his career in Game 5 (68% shooting, 34 points, 10 rebounds, four steals), a one-man wrecking crew in the first half when Miami could’ve easily fallen into a 15-point hole and found themselves on a plane ride back to New England. Wade is Miami’s heart. During the Heat’s most critical hours, Wade was there to lead them. Very few players can pinpoint what their team needs in a tight game. Wade can. Miami’s biggest weakness is their rebounding, but at the end of close games (last five minutes of a game when the score margin is within five points), Wade is averaging twice as many rebounds as he does during the rest of the game.
And down the stretch, the Heat’s defense is without parallel. You can’t even describe it. With Wade (and James) on the court in the clutch, the team’s defensive rating (team points allowed per 100 possessions) drops nearly 40 points. The Bulls get the love as a great defensive team, but the Heat are just as destructive, and they do something Chicago doesn’t always do: they can turn their defense into immediate offense. This is a product of Wade, perhaps the most devastating defender in the league when he’s playing the passing lanes.
4. Derrick Rose
The playoff vitals: 28.2 ppg, eight apg, 4.3 rpg, 47 percent mid-range shooting
No one is asked to do as much during critical moments as the MVP. Rose’s usage rate jumps to over 50 percent during the clutch just as his scoring skyrockets. But somehow, his turnovers dip in half, and he still has yet to miss an important free throw during the playoffs. While Rose has won multiple playoff games in the final moments, the Bulls are outscoring teams by less than two points during crunch time, highlighting just how much pressure they’re putting on a 22-year-old. Rose was a beast during Chicago’s first two games against Indiana, snatching two wins away from the Pacers with a combined 75 points. That set the tone. And while his start against Miami was relatively quiet (for his expectations), he destroyed Atlanta in the second round, just barely averaging below 30 and 10 for the series.
Sooner or later in these conference finals, Chicago and Rose will face a moment when the MVP will have to man up and go face-to-face with Miami’s two stars. The Bulls can’t win every game in a blowout. Down the stretch, it’ll come to Rose. And he’ll have to beat Wade and James. If the Bulls are going to make the Finals, their point guard will have to win that two-on-one matchup.
























May 20th, 2011 at 4:26 pm
LMNOP says:
cant argue with this, dirk has bin crazy good. The Lakers sweep, the 48pts on 15 shots, he’s just bin unguardable.
an on the other end, i feel bad for Westbrook. He’s showing his inexperience a lot, but some of the criticism is way over the top.
May 20th, 2011 at 4:41 pm
Diggity Dave says:
Neither Dirk or Durant will be getting those numbers against the Heat’s defense in the Finals, so you’ll be flipping around the order of things in a few weeks anyhow.
May 20th, 2011 at 6:11 pm
dapro says:
I was going to read the entire article until I saw Wade was 5th on the list. WADE set the tone for the Heat, throughout the regular season & now in the playoffs. The games he comes out assertive usually result in wins. Yeah Bron closed out the game 5 vs Boston & Game 2 vs Chicago, but check the first half in both games & see who ignites the team
May 20th, 2011 at 7:18 pm
Ian says:
And we have dudes like sporty j sayin dirk isn’t clutch
May 20th, 2011 at 9:53 pm
pharoah says:
thank you dime for agreeing with me bout lebron down the stretch why do people say that LBJ isnt clutch? did every1 forget his 2 game-winning layups in the same series against the wizards in the 1st round? how about the FATALITY he pulled off in detroit during the 07 ECFs? Even in his game 7 against the celtics in 08 (they still lost)he along with pierce was giving each other buckets down the stretch. the most recent clutchness (excluding these playoffs) was pulled off against the Magic in game 2 of the 09 ECFs. im not saying that hes jordan, or maybe even kobe. but this notion of him not having testicular fortitude down the stretch is quite funny. it seems like every time he misses a bucket down the stretch, he considered a choker. but when he hits them, people act like they’ve never seen it before.
May 21st, 2011 at 5:35 am
!!! says:
yeah MIA all the way BABY!
May 21st, 2011 at 11:24 am
doc says:
I aint mad at the list
May 21st, 2011 at 1:34 pm
beiber newz says:
i hope this list is saying who is PLAYING BETTER and not who IS better. becuz wade is def better than dirk. jus saying
May 21st, 2011 at 2:01 pm
tazb says:
July10th NBA fans annoy me
May 21st, 2011 at 2:08 pm
trollne1 says:
No Bosh on this list? LMAO
May 22nd, 2011 at 6:11 am
beiber newz says:
its funny how ppl hate on bosh. he is a great player who pales in comparison to the lebrons and kobes thats it. stop knocking him as if he is terrible. dude has been making all star teams, he carried the toronto raptors to the playoffs, his skillset is unique enuff to frustrate other bigs so give dude his credit, stop listening to media types and blogs that force u to bash his game, michael wilbon is NOT GOD. analyst do NOT have to give u your own opinion. funny, whule bosh was a raptor i known there was a large group of LAKER FANS saying they wuld rush to trade bynum for bosh. hmm all of a sudden bosh is a bum? cmon, stop comparing him to lebron and wade and appreciate whaT HE BRINGS. IF DUDE HAD AN EXPANDED ROLE HE WULDNT SUCK, HE WULD BRING SUMN to the table. bosh..i got u
May 23rd, 2011 at 1:11 am
beiber newz says:
lol and the next game bosh goes off. ahhhh i look so good saying that now
May 23rd, 2011 at 2:48 am
Matt says:
@bieber newz: I sincerely hope that you are KIDDING. there is no way in helll that wade is a better player than dirk. It’s laughable. Dirk is a top 20 ALL TIME player. Stfu
May 23rd, 2011 at 9:09 am
mdizzle says:
bosh sucks,d wade sucks, lebron is a baby, its all about Kobe!!!!!!!!
May 24th, 2011 at 12:22 pm
beiber newz says:
to number 13 !!!!!!!!
wow. here’s a simple argument becuz i dnt feel like getting into statistics (or championships) but put your playstation3 on, pop in your nba2k, and check those ratings. argument over.
May 25th, 2011 at 2:00 am
Krayzie says:
Dirk is great…..but Wade is a bit better!
May 25th, 2011 at 2:06 am
beiber newz says:
^ THANK YOU !!! no contest.