• heckler

    ATTN ALL–

    Does Shaq rank higher than Hakeem Olajuwon on the all-time great centers list?

    Can Shaq be anything better than 4th alltime?

    I heard these rankings as recently as this morning:

    Bill Russell
    Wilt Chamberlain
    Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
    Hakeem Olajuwon
    Shaquille O’Neal

    hmmm….do you all agree with those rankings?

  • kyballer312

    I guess it depends on the criteria of those rankings. Rings? Game impact? What are we using if it’s rings then he has to be at least 3rd. If its game impact (rules enacted to help defend you) then he is 2nd. I can’t put him any higher than 4th myself

    1. Bill Russell (winningest ever)
    2. Wilt Chamberlain (rule changer)
    3. Hakeem Olajuwon (smoothest)
    4. Shaquille O’Neal (most forceful)
    5. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar (best offensive weapon)

  • Ian

    depends on how u rank em
    if i go by in their primes using the 90s center i like them
    admiral
    hakeem
    shaq

    if i add how long they did it and accomplishments i would rank them
    shaq
    hakeem
    admiral

    since i have to take everything in consideration it should be shaq hakeem admiral.

    kyballer
    kareem 5th??

    heckler
    i know im the only one thats going to say this but i have russell like 6th alltime on my centers list.

  • http://www.dimemag.com Aron Phillips

    To echo what David Stern said yesterday, there will never be another Shaq.

  • K Dizzle

    Ian

    11 rings automatically put Russell no.1
    You can’t downgrade player based on the era he played in.
    Wilt’s numbers should put him 2nd.
    Kareem’s combination of numbers n rings put him 3.
    I don’t know why Hakeem always gets put in front of Shaq.
    Career:Shaq – 24pts, 11rbs, 3 as, 2.7 blks, 58% FG, 4 rings
    Career:Hakeem -22pts, 11rbs, 2.5as, 3 blks, 51%FG, 2 rings
    So Shaq ahead of Hakeem

  • Ian

    Dizzle
    Going by that russell should be 1 overall then. If you rank jordan or someone else ahead of him your list is kinda off. Now to you is russell the greatest ever? If yes then ok if no then I can rank him 6th.

  • Nyeme

    I would have

    1. Wilt – ridiculous stats
    2. Kareem – leading scorer, rings
    3. Russell – rings, but other than that….
    4. Dream – if I was starting a team, I would take Dream over Shaq
    5. Shaq

  • Soopa

    Its so tough comparing Russells/Wilts era to the current. I mean wouldnt Shaq absolutely destroy the competition back then?

    To me its Hakeem vs Shaq in the current era. Ewing and Robinson doesnt quite make the cut.

    If Hakeem had the personality of Shaq wouldnt he declare himself M.D.E.? I mean Hakeem cleaned the floor with Robinson, Shaq, Ewing, all in their prime, and they are all Hall of Fame players!

    I dont wanna decide between them. They are both dominate but with completely different styles, finesse vs power.

  • alex “robocop” murphy

    I like Hakeem over them all. I just think the quality of centers he faced in his prime was better than what Shaq has faced over his career.

    Hakeem over Ewing, Dikembe, Daugherty, Alonzo, Parish, Willis, Robinson, Campbell, Divac, Smits,

  • Ian

    Soopa
    Check the head to head stats and wins of hakeem vs robinson and shaq and tell me again if he cleaned the floor with them. Basketball reference has the head to head stats. Hakeem only desstroyed ewing (so did robinson and shaq) the others he played to a draw stats wise cuz he lost most games vs them.

    I personally like dream and the admiral more than shaq but there’s no way he ranks lower than any of them alltime.

    Btw wtf is up with the robinson (mvp, champ, scoring tile, defensive player of the year, rookie of the year) vs ewing (nothing) comparison?

  • heckler

    @ Ian–

    Bill Russell 6th best all time center?
    You do know that Bill Russell is 2nd all time in total rebounds right? SECOND EVER?
    ..and thats in an era of better shooters when there were less overall rebounds

  • Ian

    heckler
    “and thats in an era of better shooters when there were less overall rebounds”
    shit im sorry man but shoulda done some googling before posting that bs. teams back then shot high 30s and low 40s. they still avged over 110ppg shooting like crap imagine how many boards are available in a game like that. rodman has the highest rebound percentage in the nba and he avged around 7 rebs less than russell doesnt that tell you something about your era of better shooters and less rebounds. yeah hes second ever in total rebounds and??? he couldnt score like the other centers thats why i have him that low. again thanks for that made up fact you just posted there.

  • Ian

    sorry i meant “you shoulda done some googling”