Featured Gallery, NBA / Jan 23, 2012 / 12:00 pm

The 5 Best Potential Matchups In The NBA’s Rookie-Sophomore Game

Ricky Rubio

Ricky Rubio (photo. Nicky Woo)

You may not have heard, but there are reports the NBA is going to tweak the format for the Rookie-Sophomore Game at All-Star Weekend. For the previous few seasons, it was always the rookie class vs. the sophomores and while that seems great in theory, sometimes it didn’t work. Last season, the sophomores had one guy – DeJuan Blair – who put in work inside (and he’s undersized). The rookies had DeMarcus Cousins, Blake Griffin, and even Derrick Favors and Greg Monroe off the bench. So in order to make it a more interesting game, the NBA is reportedly doing something a little different this year.

HOOPSWORLD writes that there are reports the NBA will nix the whole rookie/sophomore idea and instead go with two teams made up of a combination of first and second-year players. The squads will reportedly be chosen and coached by two TNT personalities: Charles Barkley and Shaquille O’Neal. Getting past the initial comedy element (Chuck and Shaq could probably only name you five rookies in the whole league), this could turn out to be a great idea. No, they’ll be no imaginary pride factor with each class playing with something to prove. But hopefully, at least in theory, the game should turn out to be more entertaining.

If this does go down, I think it’ll make the weekend’s jayvee game more interesting. Here are five matchups I would love to see.

*** *** ***

Ricky Rubio vs. John Wall
This one’s easy. We already set off the debate here after Rubio went into Washington and put on an Beethoven-esque offensive clinic against Wall, sparking the question about just how good Wall really is. The 2010 No. 1 pick answered the bell, and is once again looking like a future All-Star. In his last five games, Wall is arguably playing better than any guard in the world. That’s not hyperbole either. He’s dropping 24.4 points, 8.2 rebounds, 8.4 assists, 1.2 steals and 1.2 blocks a night while shooting nearly 89 percent from the free-throw line (and that was against Boston, OKC, Philly, Houston and Denver). Think about the matchup like this: Wall had 22 assists in this game last year. Rubio could probably top out at 30.

Blake Griffin vs. Derrick Williams
We aren’t the first to call Williams a mini-Blake Griffin. The explosiveness, the athleticism, the body, the skill set, there are some similarities everywhere. But where they haven’t run parallel is on the court. We know what Griffin did last year. But in his first season, Williams is putting up all of 7.9 points and 4.3 rebounds a game. Yes, he’s combined with Rubio for one beautiful backdoor lob a night, but expectations were greater coming in. Griffin might slap Williams around for 30 minutes in this setting, but in reality, I just want to see some more of the real Derrick Williams. 19 minutes a night in Minnesota isn’t enough for me.

Iman Shumpert vs. MarShon Brooks
Who’s the better rookie? Take away some of the amazing things we’ve seen from Ricky Rubio and Kyrie Irving, and you’re looking at possibly the two next-best freshmen (that is if you don’t count Shumpert’s minutes as a point guard, which should’ve never happened as it is). When they matched up in the preseason, I had to watch. Part of it was the hype New York threw Shumpert’s way. But you could tell almost immediately both were players. Shumpert’s already built like a veteran, and Brooks is a slinky. Shumpert isn’t shooting very well (38 percent), but he’s one of the few guys contributing across the board in the Garden. And imagine where the Nets might be without Brooks (15.4 points a night)? He’s the only one standing in the way of a Deron Williams blow up. If Jordan Crawford got picked to play, it’s anyone’s guess who’ll lead the game in long pull-up twos off the bounce.

Kyrie Irving vs. Kemba Walker
As we wrote in Irving’s cover feature in the new issue, there were more than a handful of basketball fans who wanted Walker over Irving in the draft. He was proven. He was a leader. And he could score in any way possible. Now a month into their NBA careers, Irving is having one of the better rookie seasons from a point guard in the last 10 years (just imagine what his numbers would look like if he was getting more than 28 minutes a night). Walker is struggling with his shot (38 percent) and pitching in only 11.4 points, 3.3 rebounds and 3.2 assists a game. But in a setting like this? I think Walker could more than hold his own.

DeMarcus Cousins vs. Greg Monroe
Is Greg Monroe really the best big man from the 2010 Draft class? I’ll be honest, I missed out on Monroe, didn’t think he’d be all that good. Instead, he’s the lone bright spot (15.4 points, 9.4 rebounds) in a Pistons’ organization that has another season on life support. Meanwhile, Cousins is the better rebounder, the bigger body and probably the more talented player. He’s also shooting 44 percent (which actually increased his career numbers), turning the ball over more often and was reportedly one of the primary reasons Paul Westphal was kicked to the curb. As Chuck said recently, “DeMarcus Cousins isn’t good enough to get a coach fired.” Maybe it’s not a question of who’s the better player. Perhaps it’s only about who you would rather have for the next 10 years…

What matchups would you most want to see and why?

Follow Sean on Twitter at @SEANesweeney.

Follow Dime on Twitter at @DimeMag.

Become a fan of Dime Magazine on Facebook HERE.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Patrick

    This is a bad idea. They should keep the rookie sophomore format.

  • stillanetsfan

    i don’t know about matchups id like to see but a pairing id like to see would definitely be rubio and blake that would be scary if they were on the same team #lobcity

  • stillanetsfan

    I don’t know about matchups id like to see but a pairing id like to see is rubio and blake on the same team #lobcity

  • stefan

    Wall playing better than any guard in the world? You guys should watch some games before saying stuff like that.

    I bet anyone that there are over 20 guards in the NBA that if healthy, and given the freedom that Wall has, would put up the same numbers. The wizards suck. I watched the Nets also, d-will had only a couple of great games, but in the rest, with numbers a lot worse than Wall’s, he did a much better job running the team.

    It’s not about the numbers every time…

  • Banny

    I wouldn’t say Cousins is more talented. He has a bigger upside. Monroe has skills Cousins doesn’t.

  • http://www.livingcheapla.com hakasan

    it’s hardly fair to say that irving is having a better season than walker… irving is essentially the savior of cleveland right now, and while kemba is given the green light on a offense starved team, he’s treated like the rook…

  • cmrose12

    Enis Kanter vs. Derrick Favors
    2011 #3 pick against fellow 2010 #3 pick.

  • Sean Sweeney

    @stefan There are maybe five or six guards who could maybe put up those numbers, not 20. And yes, I do watch the Wizards.

  • stefan

    @sean I think there are more than 5-6 guards only because I see it this way:

    Let’s take a guard like Jameer Nelson who has never put up numbers like Wall. He is part of a Magic team that has been trying to build something for years. For 5 seasons now, the Magic are trying to get some players to do a good enough job to reach the finals. For this reason Nelson has the stats he does, no more than 16 ppg in a season and no more than 6 apg since he’s there. Last season Wall had around 150 more field goal attempts and 220 more free throws attempts.

    So the decrease in production of a lot of guards, or just their weak stats if they never had 20ppg and 7apg, can be due to the team’s style of play. Wall is a freak athlete but experience and freedom from your coach can also get you to those numbers that Wall has now.

  • http://www.unlimitedfblikes.com Carroll B. Merriman

    Get more Facebook Fans!! Check out Unlimited Fb Likes they are amazing! You can get Facebook Fans for a very cheap price!